Godolphin’s Good Cheer proved her superiority as the 6/5 favorite in the $1.5 million 2025 Kentucky Oaks at Churchill Downs on May 2. Saddled by Brad Cox, this homebred daughter of Medaglia d’Oro maintained her unbeaten record, winning by two and a quarter lengths in ugly conditions.
A storm before the race resulted in a horribly sloppy track. Good Cheer was covered in kickback as was her jockey, Luis Saez. His silks were brown rather than blue and her white blaze had disappeared. Fortunately this filly has tenacity as well as talent and won an allowance race by an impressive 17 lengths in similar conditions at this track in September 2024.
This was her first run in a grade one and her first time running a mile and an eighth. She had crossed the wire strongly in her previous starts, most recently in the grade two Fair Grounds Oaks on March 22 over a mile and a sixteenth. She started as the 2/5 favorite and won by three and a half lengths.
On February 15 she was the 1/20 favorite in the Rachel Alexandra Stakes (G2) and easily cruised clear of her rivals by more than six lengths. Bettors had reason to trust her after she achieved an effortless two and a half length victory in the Golden Rod Stakes (G2) at Churchill Downs in November 2024. She was bumped into leaving the gates but performed as a 4/6 favorite should. Saez did not need to use his whip.
Cox watched her closely in the Kentucky Oaks preliminaries and was pleased to see her exuding confidence, unfazed by conditions. When he noticed the cameras showing him on the video board it was a genuine smile from ear to ear.
Good Cheer is out Wedding Toast, a daughter of Street Sense, who scored in two grade one contests. She provided her 26 year-old sire, Medaglia d’Oro, with his third Kentucky Oaks winner. Rachel Alexandra scored for him in 2009 and Plum Pretty triumphed two years later in 2011.
It was a second Kentucky Oaks win for Godolphin. The race had proved elusive for many years until their homebred Pretty Mischievous scored in 2023. Trained by Brendan Walsh she was sent off at 10/1 but provided a surprise. Cox saddled Godolphin’s 2023 Kentucky Oaks 9/5 favorite, Wet Paint who had a less than ideal trip and was beaten three lengths into fourth.
For Cox it was a third score in the Kentucky Oaks. He won it for other owners in 2020 with the 15/1 shot, Shedaresthedevil and with Monomoy Girl, the 13/5 second favorite in 2018. He was originally hoping to win it this year for Godolphin with Immersive, their Breeders’ Cup Juvenile Fillies winner in 2024. She has been sidelined this spring after suffering from a bruised bone.
What happened in the 2025 Kentucky Oaks?
The 13 runners all broke well. Good Cheer got squeezed slightly as she exited the 10 gate. Carlos Davis’ Anna’s Promise (29/1) broke towards her on her outside and Kenny McPeek’s Take Charge Milady (14/1) did the same thing from her inside leaving her short of racing room.
Juan Hernandez pushed Bob Baffert’s Tenma (8/1) forward from gate eight. She had scored in her past three starts and was last seen winning the Santa Anita Oaks by more than two lengths on April 5. Whit Beckman’s Simply Joking (43/5) broke well from the two gate under Florent Geroux and closely pursued Tenma, briefly taking the lead.
Mark Casse had announced the intention to repeat the front running tactics that were successful for La Cara (8/1) in the Ashland Stakes (G1) at Keeneland on April 5 before the race. Dylan Davis obeyed instructions and took the lead on La Cara rounding the first turn with Tenma a neck behind on her outside.
Anna’s Promise and Simply Joking followed them whilst Good Cheer raced three wide in the middle of the pack. Whit Beckman’s Drexel Hill (32/1) was outpaced and trailed the field under Ben Curtis as the first quarter was run in 22.58 seconds and the half in a solid 46.78. Jose Ortiz pushed Quietside up into fourth, ahead of Simply Joking before the three quarter mile was clocked at 1 minute 11.36.
Saez asked Good Cheer to improve on her position approaching the far turn and rounded it five wide, closing on the leader, La Cara who was followed by Tenma, Quietside and Anna’s Promise. Tenma briefly took the lead in the stretch but was rapidly outstayed by Good Cheer who faced the kickback and ran clear of it.
Drexel Hill stayed on to finish second ahead of William Walden’s patiently ridden Bless The Broken (18/1) under Velazquez. Tenma was beaten seven lengths into fourth as Good Cheer posted a winning time of 1 minute 50.15.
A good day for favorites – except one
Earlier in the day in the grade two Edgewood Stakes for fillies on the turf, Casse’s evens favorite Nitrogen scored easily by three and a half lengths under Irad Ortiz for D J Stable. Todd Pletcher’s evens favorite, Fierceness, consequently fulfilled expectations in the grade two Alysheba Stakes. He took the lead approaching the wire and won by a length and a half for Repole Stable under John Velazquez.
An hour and a half later Velazquez gained another victory in the grade three Modesty Stakes run on the turf. He partnered Cherie DeVaux’s 4/5 favorite, She Feels Pretty and won by two and a quarter lengths.
The seismic shock of the day occurred between those victories. Kenny McPeek’s all-conquering Thorpedo Anna was the most popular favorite of the day at 2/5 with the American racebooks in the grade one La Troienne Stakes. She weakened when it mattered and finished last, beaten nearly nine lengths by Chad Brown’s Raging Sea (4/1).
McPeek is wondering if the race came too soon for Thorpedo Anna but saw no signs of fatigue in her work at home. She is being sent to top veterinarians to be thoroughly checked over.
The Kentucky Oaks winner, Good Cheer, is reportedly in good order having trotted up sound and scoped clear after the race. The Acorn Stakes in five weeks’ time could be her next target.

